Storytelling Instagram Reels Mistakes Beginners Make
Avoid these common mistakes when starting Storytelling content on Instagram Reels.
Avoid these common mistakes when starting Storytelling content on Instagram Reels. Instagram Reels is brand deals and lifestyle integration—Instagram's audience has more purchasing power and brands pay premium rates, and Storytelling creators can leverage cross-pollination with your Instagram feed, Stories, and DMs—building relationships that compound over time to reach People who enjoy narrative content. Here's everything you need to know.
Beginner Mistakes for Storytelling Creators on Instagram Reels
Avoid these common mistakes when starting Storytelling content on Instagram Reels.
- Instagram rewards visual polish more than TikTok. Aesthetic matters. Remove TikTok watermarks or get deprioritized
- For Storytelling, engagement from your existing followers first, then shares to Stories and DMs (Instagram's social DNA)
- Instagram's audience is slightly older (18-44) and values aesthetics and lifestyle content—adapt your Storytelling approach accordingly
- Learn from successful Storytelling creators on Instagram Reels specifically
Pro Tip: ViralNow helps Storytelling creators optimize every video for Instagram Reels.
Storytelling-Specific Strategies on Instagram Reels
What works for Storytelling content on Instagram Reels:
- People who enjoy narrative content on Instagram Reels have specific preferences—learn them
- Use #storytime, #story, #mystory to reach your Storytelling audience
- Content ideas like Personal experiences and Scary stories resonate with Storytelling viewers
- Instagram Reels is brand deals and lifestyle integration—Instagram's audience has more purchasing power and brands pay premium rates—leverage this for Storytelling
Measuring Storytelling Success on Instagram Reels
Track whether your Storytelling content is working:
- engagement from your existing followers first, then shares to Stories and DMs (Instagram's social DNA)—this is Instagram Reels's primary signal
- Engagement rate matters more than follower count for Storytelling
- Profile visits indicate People who enjoy narrative content want more from you
- Compare week-over-week, not video-by-video
- Growth is slower but more stable than TikTok—followers are more loyal and engaged long-term
Pro Tip: ViralNow tracks these metrics and shows what's working in your Storytelling content.
Instagram Reels Platform Considerations for Storytelling
Understanding Instagram Reels's unique characteristics:
- Instagram Reels uses a two-phase system: first showing to your followers, then expanding to non-followers on the Reels tab and Explore if engagement is strong
- cross-pollination with your Instagram feed, Stories, and DMs—building relationships that compound over time benefits Storytelling creators for discovery
- Instagram's audience is slightly older (18-44) and values aesthetics and lifestyle content
- Use 5-10 targeted hashtags. Hashtags are more searchable here than TikTok—people actually follow hashtags on Instagram
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the biggest mistake Storytelling creators make on Instagram Reels?
Inconsistency kills momentum on Instagram Reels. Growth is slower but more stable than TikTok—followers are more loyal and engaged long-term For Storytelling specifically, another common mistake is ignoring what People who enjoy narrative content actually want—posting what YOU want instead of what resonates. Check your analytics: engagement from your existing followers first, then shares to Stories and DMs (Instagram's social DNA). Let data guide your Storytelling content strategy.
Why do some Storytelling accounts stop growing on Instagram Reels?
Stagnant content. If you keep making identical Storytelling videos, People who enjoy narrative content gets bored and engagement drops. Instagram Reels uses a two-phase system: first showing to your followers, then expanding to non-followers on the Reels tab and Explore if engagement is strong. When engagement drops, Instagram Reels stops pushing your content. Evolve your Storytelling content, try new formats, adapt to what's working.
How do I know if I'm making mistakes with Storytelling content on Instagram Reels?
Check Instagram Reels analytics. For Storytelling content: Low engagement from your existing followers first, then shares to Stories and DMs (Instagram's social DNA)? Your hooks need work. Low shares? Content isn't resonating emotionally with People who enjoy narrative content. Low comments? You're not sparking conversation. Use data to diagnose problems instead of guessing.
What Instagram Reels-specific mistakes should Storytelling creators avoid?
Instagram rewards visual polish more than TikTok. Aesthetic matters. Remove TikTok watermarks or get deprioritized Specific to Instagram Reels: Use 5-10 targeted hashtags. Hashtags are more searchable here than TikTok—people actually follow hashtags on Instagram. Also, understand that Instagram's audience is slightly older (18-44) and values aesthetics and lifestyle content Adapt your Storytelling content accordingly—what works on TikTok may not work here, and vice versa.
Related Guides
Instagram Reels Algorithm Explained: How It Actually Works
Complete guide to algorithm on Instagram Reels. Learn proven strategies to grow faster and reach more people.
Platform GuideHow to Grow on Instagram Reels: Complete 2026 Guide
Complete guide to growth on Instagram Reels. Learn proven strategies to grow faster and reach more people.
Platform GuideHow to Make Money on Instagram Reels
Complete guide to monetization on Instagram Reels. Learn proven strategies to grow faster and reach more people.
Platform GuideBest Times to Post on Instagram Reels
Complete guide to best time to post on Instagram Reels. Learn proven strategies to grow faster and reach more people.
Platform Guide